Pushback on LEED grows

From Ohio  to South Carolina, people from building owners to state legislators are rethinking their commitment to the USGBC’s LEED certification.  Reasons range from political to economic, but amid an ever growing commitment to sustainability, there is strong demand for alternative green building certifications.

We’re not LEED-bashers at SERF.  On the contrary, we recognize the USGBC and LEED as the creators of the green building awareness movement and applaud their success.  Our mission has always been to extend the reach of this movement by making the certification process more affordable, accessible, and user-friendly.

Moreover, we help tell the story of why holistically green buildings (and sites) are important and, as a rule, good business.  Our credibility in this regard demands we honestly assess, and call out, the myriad examples of poor investments and, on occasion, detrimental life cycle effect of chasing points for the sole purpose of attaining certification. 

If I had to guess, this unintended and mounting consequence of LEED certification—together with the cost and time demand– is the root of the growing rebellion.

Has USGBC Shifted its Focus?

That’s the question posed by Greg Metz and Ted Lott of Lott3Metz Architects  in the Grand Rapids Business Journal (Click here to read the article).

Messrs. Metz and Lott were early, and proud, adopters of LEED certified designation for professionals who have wearied of the additional fees and re-certification required of their practices, which they see as little more than a new USGBC profit center.

Moreover, a sense of fairness is at play.  When they were accredited, the implied bargain was that the credential would last for life.  The revised rules, and their accompanying fees, unfairly change the terms of the relationship.  While Lott3Metz remains firmly committed to sustainable design, they are fed up with USGBC’s demand for ongoing tribute.

So instead of bellying up to the cashier window, Greg Metz would like to see, “…what is the next thing?  What’s the next LEED that everybody is going to want to have?”  Well Greg, the next thing is here.  It’s credible, it’s affordable, and it’s SERF.